10 Comments
User's avatar
Adam Amer's avatar

I used a screen reader for this work because I wanted to listen to something while working on something else. A few minutes in, I realized I’m not doing this work justice by doing so. It captured my attention in many places, mostly revolving around this idea of a “philosophical king”, which I’ve never heard before. The comparisons you’ve made between the RasulAllah ﷺ and a philosophical idea are rare yet profound, it really got me to think about how much of a mercy he is for us, amazing how eloquently you phrased it as well.

I always love seeing works that merge the world of philosophy and Islam (within its limits, of course), and this is definitely another to reflect on.

بارك الله فيك!

Zahra Hassan's avatar

Thank you so much for your kind words Adam, they mean a lot! I’m happy they could be insightful and most of all highlight the glory of our beloved prophet pbuh 🤍 Appreciate the appreciation!

Ali Bin Shahid's avatar

Jazak Allah khayr for this. I'm no scholar. Just trying to hold onto what little I understand. Post 43 (https://open.substack.com/pub/ehadnameh/p/43-the-proper-order-of-the-self?r=1ivlwg&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false) was a small attempt in that direction. Nothing polished. Just something simple, for those who find too many words get in the way. If it benefits even one heart, that's enough.

Zahra Hassan's avatar

Thank you for reading and for sharing! I’ve saved it to read later iA 🙏🏼

Amer Sakr, Ph.D.'s avatar

I love how you introduced the archetype of the new ruler.

The point that stands out for me is that you consider that he would be beyond factionalism and sectarianism.

I truly believe he's not gonna be a Sunni nor a Shiite (in the common use of the terms).

Rather he's role is to unite both under one flag.

Zahra Hassan's avatar

Thanks Amer! I do believe he’ll be a unifying force, and certainly unlike the average person. IA we see that day soon

Jawaher Humaidan's avatar

Beautifully written article, Zahra.

I love how you invited us to reflect especially in today’s world on our need for a ruler or “philosopher-king” who comes to serve the justice we all deeply long for.

Zahra Hassan's avatar

Thank you so much Jawaher :)

Mahdi A.'s avatar

Beautifully written. I really appreciate your framework and the thoughtfulness you bring to the argument!

Zahra Hassan's avatar

Thanks so much Mahdi, much appreciated!